dzham In the back burner at the moment, all my time is invested in the trading bot and the social platform. What would you like to see implemented? Right now I am a little hesitant about developing anymore for Apple since they won't allow crypto apps on the app store so I'm considering a more universal approach perhaps using Electron or the soon-to-take-the-world-by-storm Flutter.

    dzham Hi, thanks for your correction and your sheet. I updated my sheet.

      tim Hey here is a more complete description of both wallets:

      Galactica:

      Type: macOS
      Account send/receive/multi: send/receive/multi
      Account Config inflation, home, flags: yes
      Assets accept/remove/create: accept/remove
      Address Book: no
      Exchange Trade: no
      Transaction History: yes
      Network: publi/test
      Special Comment: secret stored on keychain, read only accounts

      Mooney:

      Type: Web Extension
      Account send/receive/multi: send/receive
      Account Config inflation, home, flags: inflation
      Assets accept/remove/create: accept/remove
      Address Book: no
      Exchange Trade: yes
      Transaction History: yes
      Network: public
      Special Comment: analog to Metamask, implements SEP-007 web+stellar

          It also would be interesting to know how many active users are on each wallet? Any ideas to get that information?

            dzham Umbrel has one too, can't seem to find it ATM.

            mine is here https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1DhjXMqKadHGjAV_hpMWS-ylIhv3l-zVNFjqmpeu2gGA/edit?usp=sharing
            it's outdated by now.

            tim It also would be interesting to know how many active users are on each wallet? Any ideas to get that information?

            define active users. 30 days active? non-zero balance or what? For most wallets you can't get that info. For PapayaBot I can share that.

                  Some updates:

                  Special comment/Feature
                  - Interstellar supports price conversion into major fiat currencies for XLM or any other stellar token.)
                  - Interstellar automatically funds unactivated wallets with BTC, LTC, XRP or ETH deposits.

                  Multi??
                  Does multi refer to multisig or support for multiple wallets? Anyway, Interstellar supports both multisig and multiple wallets in the same session. (Stargazer too supports multiple wallets and multisig)

                  • tim replied to this.

                    BlockEQ:

                    Type: Desktop (Mac, Windows, Linux) & Mobile (iOS, and Android coming soon)
                    Account send/receive/multi: send/receive
                    Account Config inflation, home, flags: inflation
                    Assets accept/remove/create: accept/remove
                    Address Book: no
                    Exchange Trade: yes
                    Transaction History: yes
                    Network: public
                    Special Comment: includes trade history, create and cancel trade offers

                    We will be publishing the updated Beta versions of our desktop and mobile wallets next week!

                    • tim replied to this.

                      tim Awesome list, thanks for the effort!

                        umbrel ok, thanks, interesting to see.

                        Regarding active users, I would say non-zero balance accounts. If you provide PapayaBot numbers, do you mind if I display that in the sheet?

                            blockeq thanks, I included blockeq with your data
                            fritz thanks also for your update

                                tim sure, otherwise I wouldn't provide that info.
                                it's around 1000 users as of now.

                                  umbrel it's outdated by now.

                                  Just as mine is, but you might have some interesting data points you measure.

                                    So which wallet is the most reliable?

                                    • tim replied to this.

                                      petrosan define reliable? My recommendation is to check which features you need and then check the wallets regarding the usability.
                                      @umbrel, @dzham thanks, I updated the file with your usernumbers

                                          I like umbrel's list. I would add

                                          Other features:
                                          deposit/withdrawal support
                                          encrypted private key

                                          I have a REPL based command line wallet I will release once I have deposit and withdrawal working.

                                          Thanks

                                          3 months later